Employment Law Digest August – Case Law Update
Redundancy – selection pools and meaningful consultation In Valimulla v Al-Khair Foundation: Mr Valimulla was a liaison officer, based in…
These FAQs set out the common questions and pitfalls faced by employers when dealing with issues in recruitment. The additional documents referred to are designed to assist you further. Please note that some documents are available to all readers whilst others are locked and only accessible to HR Protect clients. To become a retainer client or to find out further information please click here.
Employers who properly document the recruitment process to establish a paper trail will be better placed to justify decisions taken, to show that a selection decision was based on objective evidence of an applicant’s ability to do the job (rather than on assumptions or prejudices) and to show that they took reasonably practicable steps to prevent unlawful discrimination or harassment.
Protection from discrimination applies to job applicants in the same way as it does actual employees so, from a risk point of view it is essential that employers avoid any form of discrimination during the recruitment and appointment process, even if this is done advertently.
For further information on discrimination see:
DIS1 How to Guide: Avoiding Discrimination
Associated resource
DIS1 – How to guide – Avoiding Discrimination
Before advertising a vacancy, a written job description for the role should be compiled. The job description should cover:
When compiling a job description, ensure that an appropriate job title is used that does not show any premeditated bias (e.g. “paper boy” or “waitress”) and that the job is accurately described.
You may also wish to prepare a person specification detailing the experience, know-how and qualifications, skills, abilities and behavioural attributes necessary to perform the duties in the job description. Criteria in the job description or specification must not be discriminatory and employers should be able to justify any necessary or desirable criteria against the job in question.
It is generally considered best equal opportunities practice to advertise all vacancies externally as this will ensure that as wide a pool of candidates as possible is reached. This will not always be appropriate however, for example, in a redundancy situation, where an employer is obliged to consider what alternative employment is available within the organisation for employees who are at risk of redundancy.
For further information on redundancy see:
R1 – How to Guide – Redundancy.
Associated resource
R1 – How to Guide – Redundancy
You should consider the format in which applications should be submitted. Adopting a standardised process, whether through using an application form or requesting CVs is recommended so that applicants can compete on equal terms and to help the employer show that applicants have been assessed objectively.
Be prepared to react where reasonable adjustments need to be made for disabled candidates, e.g. providing information in large print, braille etc. so they are not disadvantaged in the recruitment process. For further information on reasonable adjustments see
DIS3 – Guidance – Disability Discrimination.
Associated resource
DIS3 – Guidance – Disability Discrimination
There is no obligation to carry out monitoring but it can help to highlight inequality in the workplace, identify the causes and help to remove unfairness and disadvantage.
Equal opportunities forms should be separated from individual applications prior to the shortlisting process and should be anonymised. Applicants should be informed that the form does not constitute part of any assessment for the job applied for and that completing the form is optional.
For a copy of the form, please see:
REC10: Equal opportunities monitoring form
Associated resource
REC10 – Equal opportunities monitoring form
There are a number of processes available to you when assessing and selecting the ideal candidate for the job advertised for example, shortlisting, selection tests, assessment centres and interviews. All selection processes undertaken must be fair, consistent and result in the appointment of the best person for the job.
You should ensure that, as far as possible, arrangements for holding tests or interviews, or using assessment centres, do not put any candidates at a disadvantage in connection with a protected characteristic. For example, where the dates or times coincide with religious festivals.
Employers are not required to make changes to recruitment processes in anticipation of applications from disabled people. However, if an employer knows, or could be reasonably expected to know that a particular disabled person is, or may be, applying for a role and is likely to be substantially disadvantaged by the premises or arrangements, then reasonable adjustments must be made. For example, if an applicant is a wheelchair user you should make sure that the premises where the interview is being held are accessible in order to remove any disadvantage that individual may suffer because of their disability.
Employers should also consider whether any tests could be indirectly discriminatory.
Using a panel of managers to consider applications is usually considered best practice.
All documents collected in the recruitment process which include the personal data of applicants must be processed in accordance with data protection legislation, in the same way as is necessary for the personal data of current employees within the business.
Job applicants should be made aware of how the employer will process the information they supply, for example via a statement in the job advert and how long it will be held for. For a template privacy notice, please see:
REC11: GDPR candidate privacy notice.
For further details on handling data during the recruitment process, please see:
REC6: Guidance: retention and erasure of employment records.
Associated resource
REC6 – Guidance – retention and erasure of employment records
Associated resource
REC11 – GDPR candidate privacy notice
Employers are not permitted to ask about the health of a job applicant before offering a job to them, except in a limited number of situations. When a job offer has been made, it can be made conditional on satisfactory health checks, but employers must not discriminate against job applicants having received the results of such checks. Health checks would usually only be appropriate where relevant to the job or where reasonable adjustments need to be considered for disabled applicants.
For more information on pre-employment health questionnaires, please see:
REC3: Guidance: pre-employment health questionnaires.
Associated resource
REC3 – Guidance – pre-employment health questionnaires
After identifying the applicant who is to be offered a job, a written job offer should be sent to the person, see:
You should ensure that offer letter is consistent with the contract of employment subsequently provided. You may want to consider making the job offer conditional on matters such as references, proof of right to work or qualifications etc.
Associated resource
REC7 – Example offer letter – permanent post
Associated resource
REC8 – Example offer letter – fixed term post
References should not be obtained until after a selection decision has been reached. This is to ensure that the selection decision is based strictly on objective criteria and is not influenced by other factors, such as potentially subjective judgments about a candidate by referees. It is also good practice to send a referee copies of the job description and person specification, requesting evidence of the applicant’s ability to meet the specific requirements of the job.
The information requested in a reference can vary. It is common to ask for information such as the applicant’s dates of employment, current role and past roles, salary and disciplinary record. However, employers may be unwilling to give all of this information and some will have a policy of only confirming factual information such as dates of employment and role.
For full guidance on receiving references, see:
REC4: Guidance: providing and receiving employment references.
Associated resource
REC4 – Guidance – providing and receiving employment references
Generally (aside from some very specific exceptions) there is no legal obligation on employers to provide a reference for a current or former employee. However, a consistent approach (whether or not to give references and what to include in them) is recommended, particularly to avoid allegations of discrimination.
If a reference is provided, the employer owes a duty to take reasonable care to ensure that it is true, accurate and fair and does not give a misleading impression. Failure to do so could give rise to claims against the employer.
All employers have a duty to prevent illegal working by carrying out prescribed document checks on candidates before employing them to ensure they have the right to work in the UK.
You are expected to keep a record that they have been carried out and repeat them in respect of any individuals who have time-limited permission to work in the UK, prior to the expiration of that permission.
It is a criminal offence if an employer employs an illegal worker and knows, or has reasonable cause to believe, that the person has no right to do the work in question in the UK. It is a civil offence if you employ someone who does not have the right to carry out the work in question, which can be punished by a penalty of up to £20,000 for each individual who does not have the right to work.
An employer will be excused from paying a civil penalty if they are able to show that they complied with the prescribed right to work checks and retained records to prove that those checks were completed correctly. For further information, see:
REC5: Guidance: right to work checks.
In order to avoid claims for discrimination, employers should carry out the same checks on all prospective employees and not just those who appear to be non-British.
Associated resource
REC5 – Guidance – right to work checks
For further information and useful documents on recruitment see:
Associated resource
REC1 – How to Guide – recruitment
Associated resource
REC12 – Employment records: retention and erasure guidelines
REC1 – How to Guide – recruitment
REC3 – Guidance – pre-employment health questionnaires
REC4 – Guidance – providing and receiving employment references
REC5 – Guidance – right to work checks
REC6 – Guidance – retention and erasure of employment records
REC7 – Example offer letter – permanent post
REC8 – Example offer letter – fixed term post
REC9 – Employee reference
REC10 – Equal opportunities monitoring form
REC11 – GDPR candidate privacy notice
REC12 – Employment records: retention and erasure guidelines
Redundancy – selection pools and meaningful consultation In Valimulla v Al-Khair Foundation: Mr Valimulla was a liaison officer, based in…
This introduces a new duty on employers to take reasonable steps to prevent their workers from being sexually harassed…
In the ever-changing landscape of UK employment law, the Workers (Predictable Terms and Conditions) Act (the “Act”) is a…
With a focus on protecting workers’ rights and promoting fair treatment in the workplace, the Labour Government has outlined…
Consideration of redeployment in ill-health dismissal In Budgen v Royal Mail Group Ltd: The Claimant, an operational postal worker, was…
From making a note of difficult conversations to recording and tracking absence the impact of effective record keeping can’t…
It has been around a decade since the European Court of Justice decided that the Working Time Regulations 1998…
The MAC’s report last month returned positive findings despite ministers’ concerns that the Graduate route was…
Limited access modeSorry, you need to be an HR Protect client to access this content.
HR Protect clients receive all the employment law advice they need across the year, delivered by experienced specialist lawyers, at a single fixed price. In addition, being a client gives you access to our templates, flowcharts and guidance notes on this Hub, where you can also return to your favourites, share content with colleagues, and manage your account.
For a full list of benefits, click here, or enquire to talk to one of our lawyers about how it could work for your organisation, and to receive a bespoke quotation.
Already have an account?
Log in below to access this content.
Enter your email to reset your password or try to login again.